In 2025, the Pittsburgh Steelers are expected to face a pivotal decision regarding their future at quarterback, as reports indicate they may have the opportunity to choose between Justin Fields or Russell Wilson—but not both. The decision stems from the team’s need to balance its long-term vision with immediate success, as both quarterbacks bring unique qualities to the table.

Justin Fields, the young, dynamic playmaker currently with the Chicago Bears, represents a forward-looking option for the Steelers. Fields has showcased flashes of brilliance with his ability to extend plays using his legs and a strong arm to push the ball downfield. At just 26 years old in 2025, Fields would align with a rebuilding or long-term strategy, giving the Steelers a quarterback who can develop into a franchise cornerstone for years to come. However, the cost of acquiring him, likely involving draft capital and a sizable contract extension, could make this move challenging.

On the other hand, Russell Wilson, a seasoned veteran and former Super Bowl champion, offers immediate experience and leadership. By 2025, Wilson will be in his late 30s, making him more of a short-term solution. Despite his age, Wilson’s football IQ and proven ability to perform under pressure could help the Steelers contend in a competitive AFC. However, concerns about his declining mobility and whether his playstyle will hold up into his late career may make the team hesitant to commit significant resources.

The Steelers’ choice will depend heavily on their roster’s direction. If they are in win-now mode, Wilson may be the obvious choice. However, if the franchise is looking to build a sustainable future, Fields’ youth and potential make him the better investment. Ultimately, financial constraints and the cost of acquiring either quarterback will dictate the Steelers’ path.